brin_bellway: forget-me-not flowers (Default)
[personal profile] brin_bellway
[cw: government bullshit]


(part 1)

---

Several personal-finance bloggers: Look, a strategy based around holding dividend stocks isn't right for everyone, but it's right for *me*. I like the psychological benefits of receiving passive income directly rather than merely implied in rising prices: it helps me keep going when times are bad. Also there's some nice dividend-related tax credits if you're holding them in non-registered accounts, but mostly it's the psychological thing.


(Several *other* personal-finance bloggers: Eh, I wouldn't go that route myself, but it's a respectable alternative if you're into that.)


Me: When it comes to finance I'm pretty big on permeating yourself with optimality facts until your emotions line up with them, and have already done so regarding [total return] and [not selling into a crash if you can possibly avoid it]. This doesn't sound like the right strategy for me. *moves on*


[weeks later, after it finishes percolating through the back of my brain]


Me: ...wait, hang the fuck on, did you just say what I think you just said? Did you just say y'all have managed to come up with a non-terrible (indeed, good enough that a bunch of personal-finance nerds consider it a reasonable choice! that's high praise!) investment strategy revolving around the holding of *individual stocks*? Holy *shit*!

That...fuck, dude, you don't know the *half* of it regarding tax efficiency! To the best of my knowledge, holding individual stocks is *completely legal*! Not "technically legal but only if the index fund humours its US-citizen holders enough to put out PFIC statements *and* you pay a specialist 500 USD/year to sort out your incredibly complicated taxes", just fucking straight-up legal!

I'll have to do more digging and probably talk it over with a tax specialist, but...psychology or no psychology, for non-registered accounts dividend stocks might simply win the "dividend stocks vs index funds" debate by *default*, the same way RRSPs win by default in the "RRSP vs TFSA, which should you prioritise contributing to" debate.

(Of course, they aren't specifically optimising for "not having to hold index funds in a non-registered account", so it's possible that there exist even better individual-stock-based strategies for people who *don't* particularly value the psychological benefits of dividends. But they seem to be firmly within the personal-finance-nerd Overton window, and if I follow their lead I can get tips from them.)

Date: 2021-06-05 04:31 pm (UTC)
thedarlingone: Peter Tork smiling (peter tork shiny)
From: [personal profile] thedarlingone
I have basically no idea what you just said but I'm glad it seems to be a good thing? ^_^

Profile

brin_bellway: forget-me-not flowers (Default)
Brin

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18 192021222324
25262728293031

Page Summary

Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 11th, 2025 03:02 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios